Season 2

Barbara Weaver’s idyllic Amish home is shattered by the ungodly actions of her husband Eli, who defies the rules of their pious, devout sect, with tragic consequences.

An aspiring artist and spiritual seeker, Elli Perkins, joins her local Church of Scientology and believes she’s finally found the path to happiness. Little does she know, her ultimate devotion will forever change the course of her life.

A trusting teenager has no idea that her first love is part of a dangerous militia group with terrifying plans to kill.

When Netta McKoy moves in with her boyfriend Peter Moses Jr., she finds out he is a polygamist cult leader trying to populate a nation of Black Hebrew Israelites.

The Amish are known for their calm and peaceful way of life. When death seems to follow one of their own, the community begins asking questions. The answers reveal a sprawling mystery filled with more twists and turns than anyone could have expected.

Kim Anderson, a divorced mother of two and devout Jehovah's Witness, finally finds the man of her dreams. But on their wedding day, she has a sinking feeling that something is terribly wrong.

When 25-year-old Christy Brown falls hard for Dave Mitchamore, she soon learns his love for her is only matched by his devotion to the Aryan Brotherhood of Texas, a violent white supremacist gang.